Industry insights
Auto dealerships lose leads every hour the BDC is closed. AI agents call every internet lead in under 60 seconds, book appointments after hours, and re-engage orphaned prospects — so your sales team starts the day with warm handoffs, not a cold call list.
Last updated
The math is brutal: the average auto dealership takes 42 hours to respond to a new internet lead. By then, the buyer has visited two competing showrooms and probably signed paperwork at one of them. Meanwhile, 78 percent of car buyers choose the first dealership that actually responds to their inquiry — not the closest, not the cheapest, but the fastest.
That gap between when a lead arrives and when a human picks up the phone is where dealerships hemorrhage revenue. BDC teams handle the volume they can during business hours, but internet leads don't follow a 9-to-5 schedule. Car shoppers research for 9 to 14 hours online before contacting a dealership, and most of that research happens evenings and weekends — exactly when the BDC is closed.
AI voiceAI voiceAn artificially generated, natural-sounding voice produced by a TTS model. Thoughtly supports a library of AI voices and brand-specific cloning. agents close this gap by calling every internet lead within seconds of form submission, qualifying buyer intent, and booking appointments — 24 hours a day, including the Sunday-night surge before Monday decisions. This isn't about replacing BDC reps. It's about making sure every lead gets a substantive first response before a competitor does.
Each of these use cases maps to a specific revenue leak in the traditional BDC model. The table below shows how AI agents address each one.
| Use Case | Channel | Outcome | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Internet lead speed-to-lead | Voice + SMS | Qualify and book appointment within 60 seconds of form fill | First responder wins 78% of buyers |
| After-hours lead coverage | Voice + SMS + Email | Engage every evening, weekend, and holiday inquiry in real time | 50%+ of internet leads arrive outside BDC hours |
| Missed-call recovery | Voice + SMS | Call back every abandoned or voicemail call within minutes | 32% of callers hang up on hold; each is a lost appointment |
| Appointment confirmation and no-show recovery | SMS + Voice | Confirm upcoming visits and re-engage no-shows same day | Show rates climb 15–25% with day-of confirmation |
| Aged lead re-engagement | Voice + SMS + Email | Reactivate orphaned and unsold leads from CRM database | Database leads convert at 15–25% when worked consistently |
When a car shopper submits a form on your website, CarGurus, KBB, or AutoTrader, the clock starts immediately. Research from MIT and InsideSales found that leads contacted within five minutes are 21 times more likely to be qualified than leads contacted after 30 minutes. Waiting from five minutes to 30 drops the odds of even reaching the prospect by a factor of 100.
Most BDC teams cannot physically achieve five-minute response times on every lead, every hour. The volume spikes — Monday morning after a weekend of accumulated leads, lunch hours, shift changes — create gaps. Third-party leads compound the problem: they arrive from aggregator sites into CRMCRMThe system of record for leads, contacts, deals, and activity. Thoughtly reads from and writes to your CRM continuously. queues that may not be actively monitored.
AI voice agents eliminate the queue entirely. A new internet lead triggers an outbound call within seconds. The agent greets the buyer by name, references the specific vehicle or inquiry, qualifies intent and timeline, and either books a time-specific appointment or warm-transfers to a salesperson on the floor. The CRM record updates in real time with the call transcriptTranscriptThe text record of a voice conversation, used for review, training, compliance audit, and search., disposition, and appointment details.
The result is not marginal. Dealerships that respond within one minute see conversion rates 391 percent higher than those that wait even two minutes, according to Velocify research. At scale, that means every internet lead gets the same sub-minute treatment — whether it arrives at 10 a.m. on Tuesday or 11 p.m. on Saturday.
Ninety-five percent of car buyers use digital research before visiting a lot. The research pattern is predictable: evenings after work, weekend afternoons, and the Sunday-night surge before a new week starts. These are the hours when most BDCs are closed.
The business impact is measurable. According to Numa's dealership research, up to 78 percent of after-hours leads are lost to faster-responding competitors. The leads don't disappear — they go to the store that answered first. A dealership running a BDC from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. is functionally dark for a third of the day, and the most active shopping hours fall squarely in that dark window.
AI agents provide full after-hours coverageAfter-hours coverageHandling inbound calls outside of business hours. Thoughtly works 24/7, so prospects don't bounce to voicemail at 2am. without extending BDC shifts or outsourcing to a third-party call center. When a lead arrives at 10:30 p.m. on a Sunday, the agent calls within seconds, has a natural conversation about the vehicle the shopper was browsing, qualifies whether they're ready to buy this week, and books a test-drive appointment for Monday morning. The BDC team walks in Monday with a calendar of confirmed appointments instead of a stack of cold internet leads.
This is fundamentally different from an auto-reply email or a chatbot that acknowledges the inquiry. Those clock-stopper responses satisfy OEM timing mandates but do nothing for the customer. As Maritz has noted, clock-stoppers during business hours are already considered outdated — they exist to hit a metric, not to convert a buyer.
Phone calls remain the highest-converting lead source for dealerships. Inbound phone calls convert to appointments at 55 to 65 percent when handled by trained BDC staff, compared to 20 to 30 percent for internet leads. But the conversion rate drops to zero when the call goes unanswered.
Car Wars data analyzed across nearly 3,000 dealerships found that the average hold time was three minutes and five seconds, and 31.8 percent of unconnected calls were customers who hung up while waiting. Each of those abandoned calls represents a buyer who was ready to engage, got frustrated, and dialed the next dealer on the list.
AI agents recover these lost calls automatically. When a call goes to voicemail or a caller hangs up after hold, the system triggers an outbound call or SMS within minutes. The agent acknowledges the missed call, asks how they can help, and works to set the appointment. Because phone leads already carry high intent, the recovery rate on callbacks is substantially higher than cold internet lead outreach.
The operational benefit compounds: BDC reps no longer need to manually work through voicemail logs and missed-call lists. Every missed connection gets an immediate follow-up, and the rep only gets involved when the appointment is set or the caller needs a live conversation.
Setting an appointment is only half the equation. Show rates at most dealerships hover between 50 and 60 percent for internet-sourced appointments. Every no-show wastes a sales consultant's time slot, disrupts floor traffic planning, and often means the buyer went elsewhere.
AI agents improve show rates by running a structured confirmation sequence. The day before the appointment, the buyer receives an SMS or voice call confirming the time, the vehicle they're interested in, and who they'll be meeting. On the day of the appointment, a reminder goes out two hours before. If the buyer indicates they need to reschedule, the agent handles it on the spot — finding a new time rather than letting the appointment silently die.
For no-shows, the agent reaches out within an hour of the missed appointment. The tone is helpful, not pushy: confirming whether something came up, offering to reschedule, and keeping the conversation alive. This same-day recovery window is critical because the buyer's intent is still warm — they were interested enough to book in the first place.
Every dealership CRM contains thousands of leads that were worked for a week or two and then abandoned. Industry data consistently shows that leads require six to eight contacts before conversion, but most BDC reps stop at two or three attempts. The result is a growing database of leads with proven intent — they inquired about a vehicle — that nobody is actively contacting.
AI agents can systematically work through this database. The agent calls each lead with context: what vehicle they originally inquired about, how long ago the inquiry was, and whether similar inventory is currently available. Leads that express renewed interest get a fresh appointment. Those that have already purchased elsewhere get dispositioned cleanly, removing dead weight from the CRM.
Database re-engagement campaigns typically convert at 15 to 25 percent appointment-set rates when worked consistently with a structured multi-contact cadence across voice, SMS, and email. For a dealership sitting on 2,000 unworked leads, that's 300 to 500 potential appointments that are currently generating zero revenue.
Thoughtly is built for exactly this problem: high-volume inbound lead conversion in industries where speed and coverage determine revenue. Automotive is one of Thoughtly's validated verticals, and the platform's capabilities map directly to every BDC use case described above.
Speed-to-lead execution.
Deploying AI agents in a dealership BDC is operationally different from other verticals. Here's what to plan for:
Auto dealerships operate under several regulatory frameworks that affect how AI agents can contact leads:
The TCPATCPAUS federal law governing telemarketing calls and SMS. Thoughtly enforces consent capture, time-of-day windows, and DNC scrubbing automatically. governs how businesses can use automated dialing and prerecorded messages to contact consumers. For dealerships using AI agents, the key requirements include:
Since June 2023, the FTC's updated Safeguards Rule requires auto dealers to implement comprehensive information security programs to protect customer financial data. Any AI system that handles customer financial information — credit applications, income data, trade-in valuations — must comply with the rule's requirements for access controls, encryption, and incident response procedures.
California (CCPA/CPRA), Virginia (VCDPA), Colorado, Connecticut, and a growing number of states have consumer privacy laws that affect how dealerships collect, store, and use customer data. AI agents that capture personal information during calls must comply with applicable notice and opt-out requirements.
This article is informational and does not constitute legal advice. Consult qualified legal counsel for compliance decisions specific to your dealership.
AI agents are designed for the first qualifying conversation, not detailed pricing negotiation. The agent confirms interest, qualifies timeline and intent, and books the appointment. Specific pricing, trade-in offers, and financing discussions happen with your sales team once the buyer is on the lot or on a warm-transferred call. This mirrors how the best BDC operations already work — the BDC sets the appointment, and the sales floor closes the deal.
The agent can be configured to check salesperson availability and either transfer the call directly or book an appointment with that specific person. If the salesperson is unavailable, the agent offers alternatives while ensuring the customer's preference is noted in the CRM record.
Thoughtly supports over 30 languages including Spanish. If a buyer responds in Spanish, the agent can continue the conversation in their preferred language. For dealerships in markets with significant Spanish-speaking populations, dedicated bilingual agent flows ensure every buyer gets a natural experience.
No. AI agents handle the high-volume, time-sensitive first response that BDC teams struggle to execute consistently — especially after hours and during peak surges. Your BDC reps shift from dialing through lead lists to handling warm transfers, working complex deals, and building relationships with buyers who are already engaged. The agents feed the team; they don't replace it.
Most teams ship their first agent within a week. The setup involves connecting your CRM or lead sources, configuring the agent's conversation flow for your dealership's specific inventory and processes, and running test calls before going live. There's no multi-month implementation or IT project.
